Note: All fields are required.
from our blog
Appellate Highlights
Appellate Highlights Caveat – Any of the Court of Appeals cases listed may currently be on review pending reconsideration. Dinsmoor v. City of Phoenix and Deer Valley USD 1 CA-CV 19-0045 (6/30/20) A high school student shot and killed his classmate and then himself off campus. The classmate had previously reported threats to the school […]
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/aa8b4/aa8b49dcab8c27211b4f09cf87378b1aa990d41c" alt=""
16 Years Probation for Mother Who Left Baby on Roof of Car
You may remember back last year when an Arizona woman was arrested after driving away with her 5-week-old baby on the roof of her car.
The woman in question had been visiting with friends until late at night, and ended up driving home under the influence of marijuana. The car seat, which had been resting on top of the vehicle, rolled off and ended up sitting in the middle of the intersection.
A passing couple saw the child seat with the crying baby inside, and called the police. The woman was apprehended at the scene of the crime when she came back, after making it all the way home and realizing her child wasn’t with her. The child was found to be uninjured, after being examined by medical professionals.
The woman pleaded guilty to misdemeanor DUI and child abuse back in February, and was just sentenced to 3 months deferred jail time and 16 years of supervised probation.
The deferred jail time only comes into effect if she fails to fulfill her probation sentence.
Mother Who Leaves Children in Car Faces Felony Charges
A recent case has been sweeping Arizona news feeds for a while now. A mother who left her children in the car while doing a job interview is facing felony child abuse charges.
While anyone in Arizona could tell you the very real dangers of leaving young children or pets in a hot car, the circumstances of this case are slightly different from the norm.
This woman, who was at the time unemployed, was unable to find child care among her family or friends, and being unemployed, was unable to afford to hire anyone. The attorney in the case against her, however, states that those factors are not important, and that felony charges are still applicable as she placed her children at risk.
Both of the children that were left in the car were taken to the hospital that day, and neither were injured in any fashion, but the dangers of leaving children alone for any period of time in a parked car are very real. Every year, children are injured and sometimes killed by the summer heat in vehicles.
Supporters of the woman state that while the dangers are real, the circumstances that drove this woman to leave her children unattended are more complicated than they might seem, and the real issue is a lack of cheap childcare for lower income families.
It will be interesting to see where this case leads, but for now, it seems as if this battle is trending towards a fight over state-funded child care.
Arizona parents struggling with child-care options
A research was conducted by a statewide team of researchers from the University of Arizona, Northern Arizona University and Arizona State University, in which they interviewed almost 1,400 parents with children from birth to 6 years old from all round Arizona.
The main purpose of this research was to know what important factors parents consider when they look for child care for their children and what are their demands.
In Arizona, the most comprehensive report on child-care demand is the Arizona Child Care Demand Study.
Douglas Taren, the lead researcher said that the findings are a valuable resource for child-care providers to determine what parents want when deciding who and where their children receive care.
Parents living in areas served by 17 regional councils who were from urban and rural areas, border counties and on Tribal Nations were included in the study and were interviewed. The results of the study showed that when parents look for child care, the factors they consider the most important are safety, security and homelike setting, with a caring and experienced provider.
A co-director of Arizona State University, Beth Blue Swadener, said that the majority of families use a patchwork of child care, often including two or more different care arrangements, with the exception being those who use full-time center-based care.
The findings of the study showed that most families use more than one source of child care due to family problems like having both parents doing the job. To afford child care, most parents reported making sacrifices because of the high costs of child care. Parents who are seen affected by the cost of child care are mostly divorced or separated. Many parents believe that it is more cost effective to have one parent stay home for the children.
According to Mary Jane McLellan from NAU, the results indicate that families often stay home and out of the workforce because the cost of care makes work impractical.
Some parents show their desire for child-care options which they can easily afford. A small number of parents reported receiving scholarships or DES-subsidized child care.
The demand for child care by parents was more among those having children 3 to 4 years of age, which was recorded at 70%. The demand for child care by parents having infants was the least at only 50%.
One other finding of the study was that parents need more public information to choose child care.
Taren said, “This study shows that what parents want in child care is consistent across the state with the most important issues of safety and affordability being the primary reason children do not participate in early childhood education programs. I believe this indicates that we need to provide more financial support for parents so their children can access early childhood education programs. This will have an immediate return on investment by allowing parents to participate more in the workforce and long term returns by having children become more ready to enter school”.
As a result of the Arizona Child Care Study, it was found that there is a need to increase public awareness of child care services available for parents who need it.
Author Bio:
Attorney Dale Naticchia is an Ohio Criminal Attorney, he has been practicing law in the Cleveland Ohio area for almost 25 years. The last 10 years have been devoted to defending drunk driving cases. Contact him and ask for a free DUI/OVI consultation
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f827c/f827c64ea86483f60b18bd715c31bad02dddf660" alt="Our Practice"
quick links
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/15d30/15d30e5305a5d1d6d21b67af06e962a5aa1f8d04" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d72e6/d72e623cdf512be53bb48151b61861e276e10c02" alt="Desert Scenery"
9375 E. Shea Blvd.
Suite 100
Scottsdale, Arizona 85260
Telephone (480) 874-2918
Facsimile (480) 588-5063